Judge A · Bronze Rumba
Try giving two couples the same place
104 117 132 Rumba: place 1 given more than once
A sheet that cannot be scrutineered never becomes a signed document.
Five judges, five couples
Marks as given | Couple | A | B | C | D | E | Place |
|---|
| 104 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 4 | 5 |
| 117 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 3 | 4 |
| 132 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 1 |
| 145 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 2 | 2 |
| 158 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 3 |
An example with invented names.
In detail The signed paper is the point
Digital marking is not new: the established systems have had it for years. What matters is that the paper record remains intact, because that record is what governing bodies rely on. A DanceFlow marksheet is not finished when the marks are entered. It is finished when the judge signs it, at which point it locks and becomes a printable document matching exactly what they signed.
- Signing locks the sheet in the database, not merely in the interface
- Reopening a signed sheet takes a scrutineer and a written reason, both recorded
- An unsigned sheet prints marked as a working copy, never as a record
A sheet that cannot be scrutineered is refused
In a final, a judge places every couple 1 to N in each dance, no duplicates, no gaps. Duplicates leave the Skating System with no defined answer, and a scrutineer has to go back to the judge while the floor waits. DanceFlow validates before it accepts a signature, so that conversation never happens.
- Duplicate places, gaps and unmarked dances all block signing
- Recall rounds are treated differently: judges are asked for a target and often land near it, which is judgment rather than error
- Problems appear while marking, not at the moment of signing
Results with the working shown
The Skating System computes placements from the signed marks, and every place records the rule that settled it, majority, larger majority, lower sum, or a widened comparison. When a couple asks why they placed where they did, there is an answer. When the rules genuinely do not separate two couples, that is reported as a tie for the scrutineer to settle rather than broken arbitrarily.
- No result can be computed until every judge on the panel has signed
- Nothing is published until a scrutineer reviews it
- Marks are immutable once signed, so any result can be independently recomputed and compared
Judges are not studio staff
A judge signs in to their own portal and sees one thing: the rounds they are marking. They cannot see another judge's marks while a round is live, a panel that can watch its own consensus forming is not an independent panel.
Questions Common questions
Does this replace paper scoresheets?
No, it produces them. Judges mark on a tablet, sign, and the system generates the hard copy matching what was signed. The paper record is preserved, which is the entire design intent.
Is DanceFlow approved by the NDCA for scrutineering?
No. NDCA approval is a governance process with a committee, and we do not claim it. The Skating System implementation is open to inspection and any result can be recomputed from the signed marks, but approval is a separate matter that no software feature grants.
What happens if judges tie?
The Skating System resolves most ties through its own rules. Where it genuinely cannot, DanceFlow reports an unresolved tie for the scrutineer rather than breaking it with an arbitrary tiebreak.
Can a judge change a mark after signing?
Not on their own. A signed sheet is locked at the database level. A scrutineer can reopen it, but only with a written reason, and the amendment is recorded on the sheet.
What devices do judges need?
A tablet with a web browser. Marksheets are built for a tablet held at the edge of the floor, and each judge signs in to their own account on it.
Does it handle multi-dance events?
Yes, including the Skating System's multi-dance rules.